Katie Thurston is on trip in Mexico together with her beau, John Hersey, and the 2 ended up hanging out with Thurston’s ex, Michael Allio, on January 13, 2021.

Thurston and Hersey jetted off for some enjoyable within the solar in early January, however ended up getting caught in Mexico on account of a canceled flight. The two are making the very best of their prolonged trip, nonetheless, and partied with some Bachelor Nation friends — together with Allio — on Thursday evening.

Several Instagram Stories of the group of obvious mates having fun with life in Cabo have been posted, and a few followers could not imagine that Thurston and Allio have been hanging out, primarily as a result of the 2 made it appear to be they have been fully in love, and that their breakup was one of many hardest that Thurston went by way of on “The Bachelorette.”

Thurston Called a Part of the Night a ‘Nightmare’

While Thurston seems to be residing her greatest life on trip together with her boyfriend after breaking issues off together with her fiance Blake Moynes in late 2021, she in all probability did not count on to spend time with one in every of her high 4 guys.

It seems as if Allio was additionally on trip in Cabo and both met up with Thurston and Hersey or all of them ran into one another. Given that Thurston and Hersey have been already imagined to be again in San Diego, this does not appear to be a deliberate get collectively.

On January 13, 2021, Thurston took to her Instagram Stories to share a photograph of one thing that she was consuming for dinner on the Sunset Monalisa Restaurant in Cabo. “On a bunch date,” she captioned the pic, including an ellipses.

Thurston then shared a video sitting at a desk with a number of mates, together with her ex, Allio, one other man from her season, Andrew Milcovich, and Luke Stone from Hannah Brown’s season. In the following video, the group was dancing with drinks in hand. Then, Thurston ended up again in a lodge room with Hersey, Allio, and Micovich.

“This looks like a nightmare,” she captioned a video of the three guys goofing round.

Some Fans Thought it Was ‘Weird’ That Allio and Thurston Were Together

Thurston and Allio went by way of a really tough breakup on “The Bachelorette,” they usually each appeared to essentially care deeply for each other. However, Allio self-eliminated to go residence to his son, James, and Thurston was left heartbroken.

It’s unclear if the 2 have been in contact for the reason that show completed airing, however they definitely did not appear to be two individuals who have been as soon as in love, in response to followers who could not assist however touch upon how “bizarre” it’s that these two have been noticed hanging out collectively.

“This is barely bizarre to me as a result of she stated she was extra devastated about Michael than GREG. Them hanging out kinda reveals me that clearly wasn’t true,” one Redditor commented on a thread about Allio and Thurston reconnecting in Mexico.

“I additionally bear in mind she considerably just lately stated he was the actual heartbreak she went by way of on her season? So that makes it a bit bizarre to me that they are all on vacation(?) collectively?” a second individual wrote.

“This constellation is a LIIIIITTLE bizarre to me not gonna lie,” one other remark learn.